In short
A brilliant move, marked !!, is a strong move that gives material away on purpose and still leaves you no worse. In a game review it needs three things: the move is the engine's choice or very close to it, it offers at least two pawns' worth of material the opponent can take, and the position is still good afterwards. A great move (!) is different: the only good move in the position.
The brilliant move is the grade everyone wants to see in their game review. It is also the most misunderstood. It is not simply a very good move. It names something specific: a sacrifice that works.
1What makes a move brilliant
In chess annotation, !! has long meant an outstanding move, usually a surprising one. A game review needs a rule it can check, so on this site a move is graded brilliant only when all of these hold:
- 1It is the engine's first choice, or within 0.2 of a pawn of it.
- 2It offers at least two pawns' worth of material that the opponent can legally take.
- 3After it, the player who made it is not worse.
- 4It is not a move in the opening book, not a recapture and not the only legal move.
The second condition is the heart of it. Leaving a knight where it can be taken, or putting your queen on a square the opponent attacks, is a sacrifice. If the engine agrees that taking it loses, or that you get more than enough back, the sacrifice is sound and the move is brilliant.
That queen move is the textbook brilliant move. The queen goes to a square where the knight can take it, and the knight has to, because it is check and nothing else answers it. Taking the queen pulls the knight away from d7, and the rook mates on d8.
2Brilliant and great are not the same
| Grade | Mark | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Brilliant | !! | A sound sacrifice: material offered, and the position is still good |
| Great | ! | The only good move: the engine's choice, where its second choice would have cost a lot |
| Best | ★ | The engine's first choice, in a position with other decent moves |
A great move needs no sacrifice at all. It is graded when the move is the engine's first choice and the next best move would have given away at least 20 points of winning chance. Finding the one move that holds a position, or the one move that keeps a win, is a real achievement even when it looks quiet.
3Why brilliant moves are rare
Most good moves keep material, so most good moves cannot be brilliant. Recaptures are left out, because taking back a piece is not a sacrifice, and so are moves with only one legal option. A false brilliant is worse than none, because it would teach you to give pieces away for the wrong reasons.
4How to play more brilliant moves
- Look for checks, captures and threats first, on every move, including ones that leave a piece en prise. Most brilliant moves are a check or a capture.
- Learn the mating patterns. Many sacrifices, like Morphy's queen, only work because the mate at the end is a known pattern.
- Solve puzzles with sacrifice themes, such as the sacrifice and deflection themes, until the ideas feel familiar.
- Check the opponent's best reply before you commit. A sacrifice that fails to one defence is a blunder, not a brilliancy.