In short
Chess annotation symbols are short marks added to moves and positions. For moves: !! is brilliant, ! is good, !? is interesting, ?! is dubious, ? is a mistake and ?? is a blunder. For positions: = is equal, ⩲ and ± mean White is slightly or clearly better, +- means White is winning, and the mirrored signs mean the same for Black. In PGN files they are stored as codes such as $1 and $4.
Open any annotated game, in a book, a magazine or a PGN file, and you will find small marks after the moves: an exclamation mark here, a question mark there, a ± at the end of a line. They are a shared shorthand that lets an annotator say what they think of a move or a position without words, in any language.
1Symbols for moves
| Symbol | Name | What it says |
|---|---|---|
| !! | Brilliant move | An outstanding move, often a surprising sacrifice |
| ! | Good move | A strong move, better than the obvious alternatives |
| !? | Interesting move | Worth playing, with risk or with ideas that are hard to judge |
| ?! | Dubious move | Probably not best, though the problem may not be clear yet |
| ? | Mistake | A bad move that gives something away |
| ?? | Blunder | A very bad move, often losing material or the game |
| □ | Only move | The one move that holds; anything else loses |
The difference between !? and ?! is the most common question. Read the first mark as the stronger one: !? leans towards good, a move that deserves attention, and ?! leans towards bad, a move the annotator doubts.
2Symbols for positions
Position symbols go after a move or at the end of a line and say who stands better. They come in mirrored pairs, with the plus nearer White's side of the sign.
| Symbol | Also written | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| = | = | The position is equal |
| ⩲ | += | White is slightly better |
| ⩱ | =+ | Black is slightly better |
| ± | +/- | White is clearly better |
| ∓ | -/+ | Black is clearly better |
| +- | +- | White is winning |
| -+ | -+ | Black is winning |
| ∞ | unclear | The position is unclear: hard to say who is better |
| =/∞ | comp | Compensation for the material given up |
3Symbols inside the moves
| Symbol | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| x | Capture | Bxf7 |
| + | Check | Qh5+ |
| # | Checkmate | Qxf7# |
| O-O | Castling on the king's side | O-O |
| O-O-O | Castling on the queen's side | O-O-O |
| = | Promotion, followed by the new piece | e8=Q |
| e.p. | En passant capture | exd6 e.p. |
| ... | A move by Black, written alone | 15...Nxd7 |
Older books sometimes write ++ for checkmate or for double check. In modern notation # is checkmate, and a double check is written with a single +.
4Symbols in a PGN file: the $ codes
A PGN file is plain text, so instead of the marks it stores numeric annotation glyphs, written as a dollar sign and a number after the move. A PGN viewer turns them back into symbols. These are the ones you will meet most:
| Code | Symbol | Code | Symbol |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1 | ! | $10 | = |
| $2 | ? | $13 | ∞ |
| $3 | !! | $14 | ⩲ |
| $4 | ?? | $15 | ⩱ |
| $5 | !? | $16 | ± |
| $6 | ?! | $17 | ∓ |
| $7 | □ | $18 | +- |
| $19 | -+ |
1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 d6 3. Bc4 Bg4 4. Nc3 g6 $2 5. Nxe5 $1 Bxd1 $4 6. Bxf7+ Ke7 7. Nd5# 1-05The marks a game review uses
A game review on this site uses the same move symbols, so a grade is never shown by colour alone: !! for brilliant, ! for great, ?! for an inaccuracy, ? for a mistake and ?? for a blunder. It adds a few of its own, drawn as icons:
- Brilliant
- Great
- Best
- Book
- Excellent
- Good
- Inaccuracy
- Mistake
- Miss
- Missed win
- Blunder